REVIEWER GUIDELINES
Reviewers are expected to provide independent, objective, constructive, and timely evaluations of manuscripts assigned to them, based on their academic expertise. Reviewers should accept review invitations only if they have sufficient subject knowledge and can complete the review within the requested timeframe.
Reviews should assess the manuscript with respect to:
- Originality and scientific contribution
- Relevance to agriculture and sustainability research
- Methodological rigor and appropriateness of data analysis
- Validity and clarity of results
- Integration with existing literature
- Logical structure, clarity of presentation, and quality of language
Reviewers are encouraged to provide clear, well-reasoned comments supported by scientific arguments and relevant references where appropriate. All comments should be written in a professional, respectful, and constructive manner to help authors improve their manuscripts.
